Paper Title:
Fractography, Some Legal Aspects and Challenges

Evidence regarding a fracture event is absolutely and definitively recorded by Nature during the fracture process. That record is in the form of the general macrocrack pattern and the surface topological features of the newly formed fracture surface. In reality, it is the only perfect record of what actually occurred during a fracture. Whenever a conflict or controversy arises regarding a fracture, it is the moral and scientific responsibility of the fractographer to analyze and interpret the record of the fracture as it was created by Nature. It is further necessary for the fractographer to then inform and educate the members of the legal community (lawyer, judge and jury) as to exactly what happened during the failure. This educational process is necessary so that the legal community can collectively understand the history of the fracture and arrive at a just and fair decision regarding responsibility and potential liability for the failure. This paper describes the overall process from the beginning of the fracture examination of the failed artifact to the final appearance in court leading to a decision by the judge or a jury. Both the technical and the human factors are addressed with varying degrees of detail.

Edited by
J. Dusza, R. Danzer, R. Morrell and G.D. Quinn
R. C. Bradt, "Fractography, Some Legal Aspects and Challenges", Key Engineering Materials, Vol. 409, pp. 28-42, 2009
Online since
March 2009
Authors: Ivo Dlouhý, Zdeněk Chlup, Aldo Roberto Boccaccini
Abstract:A number of examples exist that indicate the potential for increasing the toughness of brittle matrices by dispersing different...
Authors: J. Weerheijm
Abstract:The rate effect on concrete tensile strength can be modeled by the description of crack extension in a fictitious fracture plane [1,2].The...
Authors: Shirakashi Takahiro, Watanabe Ryo
Abstract:The effect of cutting fluids on surface characteristics of glassone of homogenuious brittle materialsare discussed. In water both fracture...
Authors: Dong Woo Lee, Seok Swoo Cho, Won Sik Joo
Abstract:A roller mill is composed of several rollers, rotational table liners, hydraulic cylinders and raw materials are ground between the rollers...
Authors: D. Tseronis, I.F. Sideris, C. Medrea, Ionel Chicinaş
Abstract:This paper studies the fracture surfaces of an aluminium hot extrusion die that broke down during operation. The die was constructed, from...