Novel, Rapidly Resorbable Bioceramic Bone Grafts Produce a Major Osteogenic Effect - The Pre-Clinical Evidence


Article Preview

Although autogenous bone grafts are currently the standard of care for bone reconstruction in implant dentistry, bone substitute materials are extensively studied in order to avoid harvesting autogenous bone. Recently, the use of tricalcium phosphate (TCP) and bioactive glass 45S5 particles as alloplastic bone graft materials for alveolar ridge augmentation and sinus floor elevation procedures has received increasing attention in implant dentistry. However, given the clinical findings with these current bone substitute materials there continues to be interest in bone substitute materials which degrade more rapidly, but still stimulate osteogenesis at the same time. As a result considerable efforts have been undertaken to produce rapidly resorbable bone substitute materials, which exhibit good bone bonding behaviour by stimulating enhanced bone formation at the interface in combination with a high degradation rate. This has led to the synthesis of a new series of bioactive, rapidly resorbable calcium alkali phosphate materials. These are glassy crystalline calcium alkali orthophosphates, which exhibit stable crystalline Ca2KNa(PO4)2 phases. These materials have a higher solubility than TCP and therefore they are designed to exhibit a higher degree of biodegradability than TCP. On this basis, they are considered as excellent alloplastic materials for alveolar ridge augmentation. In order to evaluate the osteogenic potential in vitro, we first examined the effect of various rapidly resorbable calcium alkali orthophosphate bone grafting materials on the expression of osteogenic markers characteristic of the osteoblastic phenotype in vitro and compared this behaviour to that of the currently clinically used materials β-tricalcium phosphate (TCP) and bioactive glass 45S5. These studies showed that several calcium alkali orthophosphate materials supported osteoblast differentiation to a greater extent than TCP. In specific, we were able to demonstrate that the glassy-crystalline calium alkali orthophosphate material GB9, which contains the crystalline phase Ca2KNa(PO4)2 and a small amorphous portion containing silica phosphate, had a significantly greater stimulatory effect on osteoblastic proliferation and differentiation when compared to β-TCP, preconditioned bioactive glass 45S5, and other calcium alkali orthophosphate materials of varying composition. Applying this type of in vitro assays is based on the hypothesis that enhanced osteoblastic cell differentiation in vitro leads to more expeditious and more copious bone formation at the bone-biomaterial interface in vivo. In order to test this hypothesis correlation of the in vitro and in vivo data is needed. This includes (1) correlating quantitative expression of the osteogenic markers in vitro with the amount of bone formed after bioceramics implantation. (2) Quantifying the expression of these markers in histological sections obtained from in vivo experiments in comparison to the expression of the various markers in vitro. To this end, we then examined the effect of the same selection of bioactive ceramics (previously studied in vitro) on osteogenic marker expression and bone formation after implantation in the sheep mandible and sinus floor in vivo. Of the various grafting materials studied, GB9 showed the best bone-bonding behavior and had the greatest stimulatory effect on bone formation and expression of osteogenic markers, while exhibiting the highest biodegradability. Consequently, these findings were in accordance with those of the preceding in vitro study, in which GB9 showed the greatest stimulatory effect on osteoblast differentiation in vitro. Since the cell adhesion and intracellular signaling events which lead to this stimulatory effect on osteogenesis are not fully understood, we then elucidated the mechanisms by which these bioactive bone substitutes stimulate the intracellular signalling pathways, which regulate osteoblast differentiation and cell survival. This included investigating: (1) solution mediated surface transformations, (2) serum protein adsorption events, (3) integrin-mediated cell adhesion mechanisms, and (4) intracellular signalling mechanisms. Furthermore, we then also correlated the findings from the preclinical in vivo animal studies with in vivo data from clinical studies, in which the effect of various calcium phosphate particulate bone grafting materials with varying porosity on bone formation and on osteogenic marker expression in biopsies sampled six months after sinus floor augmentation was studied, thereby rendering valuable insight in the performance of these materials in the human case as well as establishing a clinical study model for controlled clinical studies, which are required for taking novel bone grafting materials to the clinical area in an evidence-based fashion. This is in addition to confirming the adequacy of the applied animal model by correlating the in vivo animal findings to those obtained from human biopsies. Collectively, the gain of knowledge is being used to develop strategies for optimizing these bone grafting materials for a range of clinical applications so as to achieve an optimum stimulatory effect on osteogenesis. Consequently, current research efforts include studying injectable as well as mouldable resorbable calcium-alkali-phosphate-based bone substitute cements and three-dimensional calcium-alkali-phosphate-based scaffolds for bone tissue engineering purposes. This is in addition to efforts towards personalized medicine that is identifying age-, gender- and hormone status related parameters in 100 bone regeneration patients (after sinus floor augmentation with calcium phosphate bone grafting materials) which can provide powerful predictive tools toward the therapeutic outcome in a given patient thereby facilitating tailoring individual treatment regimens with respect to bone augmentation for individual patients.



Edited by:

Pietro VINCENZINI, John A. JANSEN, Kazuhiko ISHIHARA and Thomas J. WEBSTER




C. Knabe et al., "Novel, Rapidly Resorbable Bioceramic Bone Grafts Produce a Major Osteogenic Effect - The Pre-Clinical Evidence", Advances in Science and Technology, Vol. 76, pp. 214-223, 2010

Online since:

October 2010




[1] G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar and U. Ploska: Rapid resorbable, glassy crystalline materials on the basis of calcium alkali orthophosphates. Biomaterials 16, (1995) , 1241-1248.


[2] C. Knabe, G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar, J. Meyer, C.R. Howlett, B. Markovic and H. Zreiqat: The effect of rapidly resorbable calcium phosphates and a calcium phosphate bone cement on the expression of bone-related genes and proteins in vitro. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. Vol. 69A (2004).


[3] R. Gildenhaar, G. Berger, E. Lehmann and C. Knabe. Development of Alkali Containing Calcium Phosphate Cements. Key Engineering Materials Vols. 361-363 (2008), 331-334.


[4] C. Knabe and P. Ducheyne. Chapter 6 - Cellular response to bioactive ceramics, In: Handbook of Bioceramics and their Applications, edited by Tadashi Kokubo, Woodhead Publishing Inc., Cambridge, UK, 2008, pp.133-164.


[5] C. Knabe, A. Houshmand, G. Berger, P. Ducheyne, R. Gildenhaar and M. Stiller: Effect of rapidly resorbable bone substitute materials on the temporal expression of the osteoblastic phenotype in vitro. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. A. 84 (2008), 856-68.


[6] C. Knabe, G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar, Ch. Koch, S. Jonscher, A. Rack, P. Ducheyne and M. Stiller. Effect of rapidly resorbable calcium-alkali-phosphate bone substitute materials on bone formation and osteoblastic phenotype expression in vivo. Trans 8th World Biomaterials Congress, May 28 - June 1, 2008, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, p.035.


[7] C. Knabe, B. Kraska, Ch. Koch, U. Gross, H. Zreiqat and M. Stiller: A novel method for immunohistochemical detection of osteogenic markers in undecalcified sawed sections of bone. Biotech. Histochem. 81 (2006), 31-39.


[8] C. Knabe, Ch. Koch, A. Rack and M. Stiller: Effect of β-tricalcium phosphate particles with varing porosity on osteogenesis after sinus floor augmentation in humans. Biomaterials 29 (2008), 2249-2258.


[9] J. Kim, G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar, I. Shapiro, P. Ducheyne and C. Knabe: Survival and apoptosis in vitro of osteoblastic cells in contact with synthetic bone grafts Transactions 36th Annual Meeting of the Society for Biomaterials U.S.A., April 21-24, 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA, p.830.

[10] C. Knabe, G Berger, R. Gildenhaar, A. Houshmand, Ch. Müller-Mai, A. Bednarek, Ch. Koch, D. Jörn and M. Stiller: Effect of resorbable calcium-alkali-orthophosphate bone substitute cements on osteogenesis after implantation in the rabbit femur. Transactions 36th Annual Meeting of the Society for Biomaterials U.S.A., April 21-24, 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA, p.10.


[11] F. Dombrowski, U. Ploska, G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar, M. Stiller and C. Knabe: Rheological investigations on degradable and fugiline calcium alkaline phosphate cements. Key Engineering Mat. (2010) (in press).


[12] G. Berger, U. Mücke and K. W. Harbich: Determination of the internal surface of spongiosa-like ceramic scaffolds using light microscopy and X-ray refraction technique. Key Engineering Materials Vol. 240-242 (2003), 469-472.