Analysis of Properties of Reinforcing Steel Bars: Case Study of Collapsed Building in Lagos, Nigeria

Abstract:

The chemical compositions and the microstructures of reinforcing steel bars obtained from three different collapsed building sites were studied. Optical emission spectrometer was used to carry out the chemical analysis, while the microstructure was examined using an optical microscopy. The carbon contents of the steel bars were found to be higher than BS4449 and ASTM706 standards, but they are in close range with the Nst-65-Mn standard. The manganese contents of the steel bars are lower, while the sulphur and phosphorus contents are quite higher than the BS4449, ASTM706 and Nst-65-Mn standards. The hardness values of the investigated bars are higher than recommended BS4449 standard but lower than Nst-65-Mn standard. Brittle globules of Fe3P and FeS were observed within the structure possibly due to higher contents of deleterious sulphur and phosphorus. The results suggest that the investigated reinforcing bars are brittle and thus contributing significantly to the collapse of the building structures.

• Periodical: Applied Mechanics and Materials (Volumes 204-208)
• Pages: 3052-3056
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.204-208.3052
• Online since: October 2012
• Authors: Jamiu Kolawole Odusote, Adekunle Akanni Adeleke
• Keywords: Collapse Building, Hardness Value, Microstructure, Reinforcing Steel Bars, Residual Elements

References

[1] M.A. Salau: Structural Failures in Collapse Buildings. in: Paper Presented at the Seminar on Building Failures in Nigeria, organized by N.S.E., 22nd- 23rd August, Lagos, Nigeria (1996).

[2] K.O. Olusola, T.S. Ojambati and A.F. Lawal, Technological and non-Technological Factors Responsible for the Occurrence of Collapse Building in South-Western Nigeria, JETEAS, 2 (3) (2011) 462-467

[3] A.N. Ede, Structural Damage Assessments for Strength, Reinforced Concrete Beams under Static and Fatigue Loads. PhD Thesis, University of Salato, Department of Innovative Engineering, Lecce, Italy, (2008).

[4] D. Rudrappan (2010). Save our Planet. http/www.google.co.uk/search

[5] O.T. Olateju, The Need for Quality Control in the Nigeria Building Industry, Journal of Studies in Environmental Design in West Africa 10 (1993) 22-25.

[6] O. Chinwokwu, The Role of Professional in Averting Building Collapse, in: Proceedings of 2-days' seminar of NIOB (Lagos state chapter) on Building Collapse, Prevention and Remedies, Lagos Airport Hotel, Lagos 3rd -4th May 2000.

[7] S.O. Folagbade, Case Studies of Building Collapse in Nigeria, in: Proceedings on Building Collapse: Causes, Prevention and Remedies, D.R. Ogunyemi (Ed.), Ondo State, Nigeria. The Nigeria Institute of Building, 2002, pp.183-187.

[8] O.I. Fagbenle and A.O. Olawumi, Building Failure and Collapse in Nigeria. The Influence of Informal Sector, Journal of Sustainable Development, 3(4) (2010) 268-276.

[9] Information on http://www.cnn.com

[10] Information on http://www.punchng.com.

[11] A.N. Ede, Building collapse in Nigeria: The Trend of Casualties in the Last Decade (2000- 2010), International Journal of Civil & Environmental Engineering 10 (2010) 32-42.

[12] Information on http://www.nibri.gov.ng/doc/building collapse-maryland.pdf.

[13] A.G.F. Alabi and L.I. Onyeji, Analysis and Comparative Assessment of Locally Produced Reinforcing Steel Bars for Structural Purposes, USEP: Journal of Research Information in Civil Engineering 7 (2010) 49-60.

[14] British Standards, BS4449 (1997). Reinforcement Bar, Jentayu Venture, www.jentayu venture.com

[15] ASTM Standard, A706: Metals, Test Methods and Analytical Procedures, Metal-Mechanical Testing; Elevated and low –temperature Tests: Metallographic; Section 03: Vol. 01 (1990).

[16] Nigerian Standard, Nst 65-Mn: Raw Materials and Specifications for Federal Government Steel Companies, 1st Edition, (1994).

[17] R.A. Higgins: Engineering Metallurgy, Viva Books Private Limited, 2004.

[18] K. Serope and R. Schmid: Manufacturing Engineering and Technology, Singapore 2006.

[19] B. Sanmbo, E. David, A. Samson and B. Olatunde, Challenges of Producing Quality Construction Steel Bars in West Africa: Case Study of Nigeria Steel Industry, Journal of Mineral & Materials Characterization & Engineering 8 (2009) 283-292.

DOI: 10.4236/jmmce.2009.84025

[20] K.K. Charles and M. Adom-Asamoah, Strength and Ductility Characteristics of Reinforcing Steel Bars Milled from Scrap Metals, Material and Design Journal, 23 (2002) 537-545.

DOI: 10.1016/s0261-3069(02)00028-6

[21] J.J. Moore, Chemical Metallurgy: Metal Melting and Recycling, 2nd ed., Butterworth Heinmar, Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford, 1997.