Construction Contract Clarity: Conceptual Process Flow Modeling

Abstract:

Construction contracts can be a complex subject if issues corresponding to their interpretation and administration are not handled properly. The need for clarity of construction contracts is eminent especially in the context of the construction industry. The paper holds that a better interpretation and understanding of construction contracts could offer a proactive approach to avoid the inevitability of conflicts occurring in a project. Therefore, the objective of this paper is to develop a conceptual process flow model on how to clarify contract provisions in a contract. It is a subsequent development from the survey and case study that carried out for Malaysian Public Works Department (PWD) -203A (Rev. 10/83) Contract Form. The model is based on the results on the survey and case study, but it designed to render a generic approach of clarifying process for other contracts. Data Flow Diagram (DFD) method was selected to illuminate the process flow as the method focuses on object perspective and appropriate for this development. Certain limitations and recommendations of the model were highlighted. Ultimately, the model renders a useful guideline for future contract drafting and an important insight on clarity approach in contract administration for dispute avoidance.

• Periodical: Applied Mechanics and Materials (Volume 145)
• Pages: 344-348
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.145.344
• Online since: December 2011
• Authors: Heap Yih Chong, Chai Chai Lim, Rosli Mohamad Zin
• Keywords: Construction Industry, Contract Provisions, DFD, Modeling Industry, PWD 203

References

[1] E. Martin: Prof. Issues in Eng. Edu. and Prac. Vol 119 (1993), p.147.

[2] J.C. Broome and R. W. Hayes: Int. J. of Pro. Manage. Vol 15 (1997), p.255.

[3] R. Rameezdeen and C. Rajapakse: Constr. Manage. & Eco. Vol 25 (2007), p.729.

[4] R. Shumway, A. Richard and J. Ritti: Lead. & Manage. in Eng. Vol 4 (2004), p.93.

[5] M. Cutts: Oxford Guide to Plain English (Oxford University Press, New York 2004).

[6] J.M. Feinman: 1001 Legal Words You Need to Know (Oxford University Press, New York 2003).

[7] H. Henkin: Drafting Engineering Contracts (Elsevier Applied Science Publishers Ltd., New York 1998).

[8] C.A. Hill: Why Contracts are Written in Legalese, (Kent College of Law, Chicago 2001).

[9] M.I. Mohamad and M. Zulkifli: Understanding Contract Documentation, Proceedings of the 6th Asia-Pacific Structural Engineering and Construction Conference, (2006) Sept. 5-6; UTM, Malaysia.

[10] C.F. Lim: The Malaysian PWD Form of Construction Contract (Sweet & Maxwell Asia, Selangor 2004).

[11] H.R. Thomas, G.R. Smith and R.E. Mellott: J. of Constr. Eng. & Manage. Vol 120 (1994), p.321.

[12] S. Styllis: Constructing Construction Contract: the Need for Clarity (Reed Business Information, Sutton 2005).

[13] H.Y. Chong and M.Z. Rosli: Int. J. Pro. Manage. Vol 28 (2010), p.601.

[14] C.N. Candlin, V.K. Bhatia and C.H. Jensen: J. of Eng. for Spec. Purp. Vol 21 (2002), p.299.

[15] C.Y.L. Melissa: New Engineering Contract (NEC) 1993 as Radical Changes to the Malaysian Standard Forms of Contract (Master Thesis. University of Technology Malaysia, Malaysia 2006).

[16] W.H. Luo and Y.A. Tung: J. of Ind. Manage. & Data Syst. Vol 99 (1999), p.312.

[17] A.S.M. Tam, L.K. Chu and D. Sculli: J. of Ind. Manage. & Data Syst. Vol 101 (2001), p.144.