Experimental and Computational Validation of Dissipative Prototype for the Seismic Protection of Heritage Buildings

Abstract:

Since earthquakes such as Northbridge (1994) and Kobe (1995) gave the impetuous for the development of performance-based design methods, engineers have been strenuously working to the improvement of the seismic behaviour of structures; in fact, high ductility frames, as well as damping and isolation systems, are nowadays common practice in seismic prone areas. Heritage buildings constitute an odd case: many historic centres are still considerably affected by seismic events (L’Aquila, 2009) due to the lack of a methodical retrofit and this, where applied, is still largely based on the increase of stiffness and capacity, without the due care for precious finishings. In order to address the lack of specific passive systems for heritage buildings, the authors have developed two typologies of dissipative devices that can be integrated in traditional steel anchors and installed within the masonry at the joints of perpendicular walls, where out-of-plane mechanisms are likely to form due to poor quality connections. Both prototypes, one based on the plasticity of steel, the other relying on friction, were tested as isolated elements in pseudo-static regime for proofing and fine tuning, and in a dynamic range typical of the seismic frequency content to validate the stability of dissipative loops. The paper focuses on pull-out tests aimed to analyse the behaviour of the hysteretic prototype in respect to traditional steel anchors in masonry panels with low shear capacity. Finite Element (FE) models were also developed and calibrated applying the data from tests. Experimental and computational results are discussed in the following; the need for further theoretical work concludes the paper.

• Periodical: Advanced Materials Research (Volumes 133-134)
• Pages: 831-836
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.133-134.831
• Online since: October 2010
• Authors: Sara Paganoni, Dina D’Ayala
• Keywords: Dissipative, Heritage Buildings, Masonry Structure, Seismic Passive Protection, Steel Anchor

References

[1] BS EN 1015: 1999 - Methods of Test for Mortar for Masonry, (1999).

[2] BS EN 1052: 1999 - Methods of Test for Masonry, (1999).

[3] BS EN 1996-1-1: 2005 Eurocode 6 - Design of Masonry Structures, (2000).

[4] BS EN 772: 2000 - Methods of Test for Masonry Units, (2000).

[5] BS EN 846-2: 2000 - Methods of Test for Ancillary Components for Masonry, Part 2: Determination of Bond Strength of Prefabricated Bed Joint Reinforcement in Mortar Joints, (2000).

DOI: 10.3403/02027528u

[6] D'Ayala, D. and Paganoni, S (2010). Assessment and Analysis of Damage in L'Aquila after 6th April 2009., Submitted for publication in special issue of the Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[7] EN 1993-1-4: 2006 Eurocode 3 - Design of steel structures, Annex C, (1996).

[8] EN 1998 Eurocode 8 - Design of Structures for Earthquake Resistance, (1998).

[9] Indirli, M, and Castellano, M G (2008). Shape Memory Alloy Device for the Structural Improvement of Masonry Heritage Structures., International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2: 93-119.

DOI: 10.1080/15583050701636258

[10] Italian Ministry of Cultural Heritage and Activities (2006). Guidelines for Evaluation and Mitigation of Seismic Risk to Cultural Heritage.

[11] Paganoni, S, and D'Ayala, D (2009). Development and Testing of Dissipative Anchor Devices for the Seismic Protection of Heritage Buildings, in Proc. of ANCER Workshop (2009).

[12] Priestley, M J N (2000). Performance Based Seismic Design, in Proc. of 12 th World Conference of Earthquake Engineering, paper No. 2831.

[13] Tomaževič, M (1999). Earthquake-resistant Design of Masonry Buildings., A. S. Elnashai & P. J. Dowling Ed., London, UK: Imperial College Press.

[14] Zhou, Z , Walker, P , and D'Ayala, D (2008). Strength Characteristics of Hydraulic Lime Mortared Brickwork, in Proc. of the Institution of Civil Engineering - Construction Materials, 161(4)，139-146.

DOI: 10.1680/coma.2008.161.4.139