System Identification and IMC-Based PID Control of a Reactive Distillation Process: A Case Study of n-Butyl Acetate Production

Abstract:

The identification of a reactive distillation system for the production of n-butyl acetate from the esterification reaction between acetic acid and n-butanol has been carried out in this research work. In order to achieve the aim of the research work, a prototype plant of the process was developed using ChemCAD from which dynamics data were generated upon applications of step changes to the reboiler duty and the reflux ratio, which were the input variables of the system. Thereafter, the transfer function of the process, later represented in Simulink environment, was formulated using the dynamics data and with the aid of MATLAB. The simulation of the transfer function model of the system was also carried out for open loop by applying step changes unto the input variables using the developed Simulink model of the system. Thereafter, the closed-loop control system developed also in Simulink environment was simulated by applying step changes to the set-point variable, which was the bottom mole fraction of n-butyl acetate. The results obtained from the simulation of the prototype plant of the reactive distillation process showed ChemCAD to be a powerful tool for steady state and dynamics prototype plant development. Furthermore, good representation and stability were also observed to exist in the system from the formulation and the simulation of the transfer function model of the process, which were carried out with the aid of MATLAB/Simulink. Moreover, the selection of appropriate closed-loop time constant contained in the tuning parameter formulas of IMC-based control system showed that the value suggested by Rivera et al. [1] was very good for this system, compared to those of Chien and Fruehauf [2] and Skogestad [3], because it could give closed-loop dynamic response with comparatively very low values of integral squared error (ISE), integral absolute error (IAE) and integral time absolute error (ITAE) for both proportional-integral (PI) and proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control systems. In addition, the comparison made between the IMC-based tuning approach and other ones (Cohen-Coon, Tyreus-Luyben and Ziegler-Nichols) considered in this work made it known that IMC-based tuning technique was the best among all those considered because its ISE, IAE and ITAE were found to be the lowest for both PI-and PID-controlled cases simulated.

• Periodical: International Journal of Engineering Research in Africa (Volume 31)
• Pages: 104-119
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/JERA.31.104
• Online since: July 2017
• Authors: Abdulwahab Giwa*, John Olusoji Owolabi, Saidat Olanipekun Giwa
• Keywords: Chemcad, Internal Model Control (IMC), N-Butyl Acetate, Reactive Distillation, Simulation, Transfer Function Modelling

References

[1] D.E. Rivera, M. Morari, and S. Skogestad, internal model control. 4. PID controller design, Ind. Eng. Process Design Dev., 25(1) (1986) 252-265.

DOI: 10.1021/i200032a041

[2] I.L. Chien, and P. S. Fruehauf, Consider IMC tuning to improve controller performance, Chemistry Engineering Progress, 86(10) (1990) 33-41.

[3] S. Skogestad, Simple analytic rules for model reduction and PID controller tuning, J. Process Control, 13(4) (2003) 291-309.

DOI: 10.1016/s0959-1524(02)00062-8

[4] V.H. Agreda, L.R. Partin, and W.H. Heise, High purity methyl acetate via reactive distillation, Chemical Engineering Progress, 86(2) (1990) 40-46.

[5] D. Barbosa, and M.F. Doherty, The simple distillation of homogeneous reactive mixtures, Chemical Engineering Science, 43 (1988) 541-550.

DOI: 10.1016/0009-2509(88)87015-5

[6] B. Bessling, G. Schembecker, and K.H. Simmrock, Design of processes with reactive distillation line diagrams, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 36(8) (1997) 3032-3042.

DOI: 10.1021/ie960727p

[7] B. Bessling, J.M. Loning, A. Ohligschläger, G. Schembecker, and K. Sundmacher, Investigations on the synthesis of methyl acetate in a heterogeneous reactive distillation process, Chemical Engineering Technology, 21 (1998) 393-400.

DOI: 10.1002/(sici)1521-4125(199805)21:5<393::aid-ceat393>3.0.co;2-9

[8] A. Giwa, Steady-state modeling of n-butyl acetate transesterification process using Aspen Plus: conventional versus integrated, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 7(12) (2012) 1555-1564.

[9] A. Giwa, Methyl acetate reactive distillation process modeling, simulation and optimization using Aspen Plus. ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 8(5) (2013) 386-392.

[10] S.O. Giwa, A. Giwa, and H. Hapoglu, Investigating the effects of some parameters on hydrogen sulphide stripping column using Aspen HYSYS, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 8(5) (2013) 338-347.

[11] A. Giwa, S.O. Giwa, and H. Hapoglu, Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference Systems (ANFIS) modeling of reactive distillation process, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 8(7) (2013) 473-479.

[12] A. Giwa, S.O. Giwa, and A.A. Adeyi, Dynamics and servo control of biodiesel purity from a reactive distillation process, International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 6(8) (2015) 146-156.

[13] A. Giwa, A. Bello, and S.O. Giwa, Performance analyses of fatty acids in reactive distillation process for biodiesel production, International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 5(12) (2014) 529-540.

[14] A. Giwa, A. Bello, and S.O. Giwa, Artificial neural network modeling of a reactive distillation process for biodiesel production, International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 6(1) (2015) 1175- 1191.

[15] A. Giwa, and S. Karacan, Simulation and optimization of ethyl acetate reactive packed distillation process using Aspen Hysys, The Online Journal of Science and Technology, 2(2) (2012) 57-63.

[16] A. Giwa, and S. Karacan, Nonlinear black-box modeling of a reactive distillation process, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 1(7) (2012) 548-557.

[17] A. Giwa, and S. Karacan, Decoupling Control of a reactive distillation process using Tyreus-Luyben Technique, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 7(10) (2012) 1263-1272.

[18] A. Giwa, and S.O. Giwa, Isopropyl myristate production process optimization using response surface methodology and MATLAB, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 2(1) (2013) 853-862.

[19] A. Giwa, and S.O. Giwa, Estimating the optimum operating parameters of olefin metathesis reactive distillation process, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 8(8) (2013) 614-624.

[20] A. Giwa, S.O. Giwa, İ. Bayram, and S. Karacan, Simulations and economic analyses of ethyl acetate productions by conventional and reactive distillation processes using Aspen Plus, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 2(8) (2013).

[21] A. Giwa, Solving the dynamic models of reactive packed distillation process using difference formula approaches, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 9(2) (2014) 98-108.

[22] A. Giwa, and S.O. Giwa, Modelling and simulation of a reactive distillation process for fuel additive production, Journal of Environmental Science, Computer Science and Engineering & Technology, Section C: Engineering & Technology, 5(1) (2016).

[23] A. Giwa, and S. Karacan, Modeling and simulation of a reactive packed distillation column using delayed neural networks, Chaotic Modeling and Simulation, 2(1) (2012) 101-108.

[24] A. Giwa, and S.O. Giwa, Layer-recurrent neural network modelling of reactive distillation process, Chaotic Modeling and Simulation, 2(4) (2013) 647-656.

[25] A. Giwa, and S. Karacan, Development of dynamic models for a reactive packed distillation column, International Journal of Engineering, 6(3) (2012) 118-128.

[26] R.C. Anene, and A. Giwa, Modelling, simulation and sensitivity analysis of a fatty acid methyl ester reactive distillation process using aspen plus, International Journal of Engineering Research in Africa, 27 (2016) 36-50.

DOI: 10.4028/www.scientific.net/jera.27.36

[27] S.O. Giwa, A.A. Adeyi, and A. Giwa, Application of model predictive control to renewable energy development via reactive distillation process, International Journal of Engineering Research in Africa, 27 (2016) 95-110.

DOI: 10.4028/www.scientific.net/jera.27.95

[28] A. Giwa, and S.O. Giwa, Optimization of transesterification reaction integrated distillation column using Design Expert and Excel Solver, International Journal of Advanced Scientific and Technical Research, 2(6) (2012) 423-435.

[29] D.R. Coughanowr, Process Systems Analysis and Control, 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York, (1991).

[30] C.E. Garcia, and M. Morari, Internal Model Control I. A Unifying Review and Some New Results, Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev., 21(2) (1982) 308-323.

DOI: 10.1021/i200017a016

[31] D.E. Seborg, T.F. Edgar, and D.A. Mellichamp, Process Dynamics and Control. 2nd Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New Jersey, USA, (2004).

[32] D. Muhammad, Z. Ahmad, and N. Aziz, Implementation of internal model control (IMC) in continuous distillation column, Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on Design, Operation and Control of Chemical Processes, 5 (2010) 812-821.

[33] R.K. Wood, and M.W. Berry, Terminal composition control of a binary distillation column, Chemical Engineering Science, 28 (1973) 1707-1717.

DOI: 10.1016/0009-2509(73)80025-9

[34] J.M. Wassick, and R.L. Tummala, Multivariable internal model control for a full-scale industrial distillation column, IEEE Control Systems Magazine, 9 (1989) 91-96.

DOI: 10.1109/37.16758

[35] M.S. Basualdo, R.A. Calvo, and H.A. Ceccatto, Neural control strategies of a binary distillation column, In IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, (1994) 77-81.

DOI: 10.1109/isie.1994.333135

[36] A.M. Shaw, and F.J. Doyle III, Multivariable nonlinear control applications for a high purity distillation column using a recurrent dynamic neuron model, Journal of Process Control, 7 (1997) 255-268.

DOI: 10.1016/s0959-1524(97)00002-4

[37] R.W. Jones, and M.T. Tham, A comparison of simple robust PI design methods: Studies on a multivariable system. In Proceedings of the SICE Annual Conference, (2004) 599-604.

[38] E. Castellanos-Sahagun, J. Alvarez-Ramirez, and J. Alvarez, Two-point temperature control structure and algorithm design for binary distillation columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 44 (2005) 142-152.

DOI: 10.1021/ie0401096

[39] K. Razzaghi, and F. Shahraki, Robust control of an ill-conditioned plant using [mu]-synthesis: A case study for high-purity distillation, Chemical Engineering Science, 62 (2007) 1543-1547.

DOI: 10.1016/j.ces.2006.11.045

[40] Chemstations, CHEMCAD 6. 5. 7. 8139. Chemstations Inc, Texas, (2015).

[41] MathWorks, MATLAB, The Language of Technical Computing. The MathWorks, Inc., Natick, (2016).

[42] G. Stephanopoulos, Chemical Process Control: An Introduction to Theory and Practice, PTR Prentice Hall, New Jersey, (1984).