Evaluation of Nuclear Piping Failure Frequency in Korean Pressurized Water Reactors

Abstract:

The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the piping failure frequency based on the piping failure events in Korean pressurized water reactors (PWRs) until the end of 2003. Two types of the piping failure frequencies including the piping damage frequency and the piping rupture frequency are considered in this study. The piping damage frequency for the failed piping system was estimated by using the piping population data such as the weld count or the base metal count. The piping rupture frequency related to the initiating event in a probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) was evaluated by using both the Bayesian approach (Method 1) and the conditional rupture probability approach (Method 2). In the Bayesian approach, two methods using Jeffreys noninformative prior (Method 1-1) and prior distributions based on the results in NUREG/CR-5750 (Method 1-2) were considered. Thirty piping failure events in ASME safety class pipings of Korean PWRs were identified and analyzed in this study. The results showed that the piping damage frequency for the events ranged from 5.42E-3/cr.yr to 2.77E-5/cr.yr. Three kinds of initiating events including the very small LOCA, the feedwater line break, and the flood are evaluated for Korean PWRs. The results for the piping rupture frequency in Korean PWRs were as follows: 1) The mean piping rupture frequency of the very small LOCA event ranged from 3.6E-3/cr.yr to 1.2E-2/cr.yr, the feedwater line break event from 3.6E-3/cr.yr to 2.5E-2/cr.yr, and the flood event from 7.8E-4/cr.yr to 3.6E-3/cr.yr. The mean piping rupture frequencies of the very small LOCA and feedwater line break events were higher than that of the flood event by one order of a magnitude. 2) Method 2 gave conservative results in the very small LOCA and feedwater line break events compared to Method 1-1 or Method 1-2, while Method 1-1 gave conservative results in the flood event. 3) The order of magnitudes in the mean piping rupture frequencies of the very small LOCA, the feedwater line break, and the flood in Korean PWRs were similar to those in the U.S. PWRs.

• Periodical: Key Engineering Materials (Volumes 297-300)
• Pages: 1645-1651
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/KEM.297-300.1645
• Online since: November 2005
• Authors: Sun Yeong Choi, Young Hwan Choi
• Keywords: Piping Damage Frequency, Piping Rupture Frequency, Pressurized Water Reactor

References

[1] USNRC: Pipe Cracking Experience in LWR, NUREG-0679 (1980).

[2] USNRC: Investigation and Evaluation of Cracking Incidents in Piping in PWR, NUREG-0691 (1980).

[3] USNRC: Erosion/Corrosion-Induced Pipe Wall Thinning in US NPPs, NUREG-1344 (1989).

[4] EPRI: Nuclear Reactor Piping Failures at US Commercial LWRs, 1961 - 1997, EPRI TR-110102, (1998).

[5] SKI, SKI Database: Reliability of Piping System Components (1997).

[6] OECD/NEA: OPDE Database (rev. 0. f), OECD Piping Failure Data Exchange (OPDE) Project (2004).

[7] S.Y. Choi and Y.H. Choi: Piping Failure Analysis in Korean Nuclear Piping including the Effect of ISI, Key Engineering materials Vol. 270-273, pp.1731-1736 (2004).

DOI: 10.4028/www.scientific.net/kem.270-273.1731

[8] USNRC: Rate of Initiating Events at U.S. Nuclear Power Plants, 1987-1995, NUREG/CR-5750 (1998).

[9] S.Y. Choi and Y.H. Choi: Development of OPDE Database, 2002 Fall Conference of KNS, Yong-Peong (2002).

[10] S.Y. Choi and Y.H. Choi: Piping Failure Analysis in Domestic Nuclear Safety Piping System, 2003 Spring Conference of KSME, Pusan (2003).

[11] S. Beliczey and H Schulz: Comments on Probabilities of Leaks and Breaks of Safety-Related Piping in PWR Plants, International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping Vol. 43 (1990), pp.219-227.

DOI: 10.1016/0308-0161(90)90103-o

[12] USNRC: WinPRAISE, Engineering Mechanics Technology (1998).

[13] V.N. Shah and P.E. Macdonald: Aging and Life Extension of Major Light Water Reactor Component, Elsevier (1993).

[14] S.Y. Choi and Y.H. Choi: Piping Failure Frequency Analysis for the Main feedwater System in Domestic Nuclear Power Plants, Journal of Korean Nuclear Society Vol. 36 No. 1 (2003).

[15] Shrir, Corrosion, Newnes-butterworths, London (1979).