Masonry Spires: 3D Models to Understand their Seismic Vulnerability

Abstract:

The May 2012 Emilia earthquake has highlighted the important vulnerability of masonry spires at the top of bell towers of churches. Indeed, almost half of those in the epicentral area have shown a typical damage mechanism consisting in the shear sliding and overturning of the top of the spire. Given the recurrence of this phenomenon, the present paper tries to provide a contribution to the comprehension of the seismic behaviour of the spires through the numerical analysis of three case studies. In particular, the work analyses the spires of the churches of San Nicola di Bari in Cortile, near Carpi (MO); Sant'Egidio in Cavezzo (MO), and Sant'Agostino in Sant'Agostino (FE). The numerical models of these masonry structures were made using Abaqus Finite Element software. After the creation of the three-dimensional geometric models, a first nonlinear static analysis of the entire bell tower was performed adopting for masonry the Abaqus “concrete damage plasticity model”. Once the stability of the bell tower was verified for dead loads, the non-linear time-step dynamic analysis was faced. This required the definition of the seismic input at the base of the tower, through the accelerograms recorded by the closest stations. The nonlinear dynamic analysis of the global model of the bell tower provided the floor response spectra at the base and at the top of the spire. Indeed the comparison between spectra at the ground and at the top highlights the filter effect of the stem of the bell tower with a significant increase in accelerations at the top. This effect may explain the widespread damage observed at the top of the spires. Eventually, three different non-invasive intervention techniques were proposed in compliance with the principles of restoration and were modelled to compare their behaviour.

• Periodical: Key Engineering Materials (Volume 817)
• Pages: 317-324
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/KEM.817.317
• Online since: August 2019
• Authors: Elena Zanazzi*, Eva Coïsson, Daniele Ferretti, Alessio Lorenzelli
• Keywords: Masonry, Seismic Damage, Spire, Tower

References

[1] Di Francesco C. (Eds.), A sei mesi dal sisma, Bologna 2014, pp.29-32.

[2] D. Ferretti; E. Coïsson, The seismic vulnerability of towers' masonry spires: learning from history, in Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Structural Analysis of Historical Construction, (2014) - ISBN:978-3-43360-444-1.

[3] A. Lorenzelli, The seismic vulnerability of bell-towers' spires: damage analysis and modeling, thesis in Engineering, University of Parma, supervisors D. Ferretti, E. Coïsson, A.Y. 2016/(2017).

[4] M. J. DeJong, Seismic response of stone masonry spires: Analytical modeling, Engineering Structures, 40, 556-565, (2012).

DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2012.03.010

[5] A. Cigada, L. Corradi Dell'Acqua, B. Mörlin Visconti Castiglione, M. Scaccabarozzi, M. Vanali, E. Zappa, Structural health monitoring of an historical building: The main spire of the Duomo di Milano, International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 1.4, 501-518, (2017).

DOI: 10.1080/15583058.2016.1263691

[6] Ministry for Cultural Heritage and Activities, Guidelines for the evaluation and mitigation of seismic risk to cultural heritage, Gangemi Editore, Roma (2008) ISBN10 88-492-1269-0.

[7] E. Zanazzi, BALANCING ON TIPTOES, Overview of the spires damaged by 2012 earthquake, georeferenced analysis and strengthening proposals, thesis in Architecture, University of Parma, supervisors E. Coïsson, D. Ferretti, B. Caselli, A.Y. 2016/(2017).

[8] Blasi C., Il consolidamento dei campanili danneggiati dal sisma: riflessioni su conservazione e sicurezza, in Di Francesco C. (a cura di), A sei mesi dal sisma, Bologna 2014, pp.230-232.

[9] Abaqus, Theory Manual, Version 6.14 (2014).

[10] G. Barbieri, L. Biolzi, M. Bocciarelli, L. Fregonese, A. Frigeri, Assessing the seismic vulnerability of a historical building, Engineering Structures, 57:523-535, (2013).

DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2013.09.045

[11] M. Valente, G. Barbieri, L. Biolzi, Seismic assessment of two masonry Baroque churches damaged by the Emilia earthquake, Engineering Failure Analysis, 2017, 79: 773-802.

DOI: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2017.05.026

[12] M. Valente, G. Milani, Non-linear dynamic and static analyses on eight historical masonry towers in the North-East of Italy, Engineering Structures, 2016, 114: 241-270.

DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2016.02.004

[13] G. Castellazzi, A. M. D'Altri, S. de Miranda, A. Chiozzi, A. Tralli, Numerical insights on the seismic behaviour of a non-isolated historical masonry tower, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2017 1-29.

DOI: 10.1007/s10518-017-0231-6

[14] M. Valente, G. Barbieri, L. Biolzi, Damage assessment of three medieval churches after the 2012 Emilia earthquake, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2017, 1-42.

DOI: 10.1007/s10518-016-0073-7

[15] M. Acito, M. Bocciarelli, C. Chesi, G. Milani, Collapse of the clock tower in Finale Emilia after the May 2012 Emilia Romagna earthquake sequence: Numerical insight, Engineering Structures, 2014, 72: 70-91.

DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2014.04.026

[16] G. Milani, M. Valente, Failure analysis of seven masonry churches severely damaged during the 2012 Emilia-Romagna (Italy) earthquake: non-linear dynamic analyses vs conventional static approaches, Engineering Failure Analysis, 2015, 54: 13-56.

DOI: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2015.03.016

[17] Information on http://itaca.mi.ingv.it.

[18] I. Di Cocco, Dalla lista dei danni alla mappa del tesoro. […], in: Di Francesco C. (Eds.), A sei mesi dal sisma, Bologna 2014, pp.119-120.

[19] Castellazzi G., D'Altri A.M., De Miranda S., Ubertini F., An innovative numerical modeling strategy for the structural analysis of historical monumental buildings, Engineering Structures, 2017, 132: 229-248.

DOI: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2016.11.032

[20] R. W. Clough, J. Penzien, Dynamics of structures, McGraw-Hill, New York, (1993).

[21] L. Zanotti Fragonara, G. Boscato, R. Ceravolo, S. Russo, S. Ientile, M. L. Pecorelli, A. Quattrone, Dynamic investigation on the Mirandola bell tower in post-earthquake scenarios, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2017, 15:313-337.

DOI: 10.1007/s10518-016-9970-z

[22] S. Casolo, V. Diana, G. Uva, Influence of soil deformability on the seismic response of a masonry tower, in Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2017, 15.5: 1991-2014.

DOI: 10.1007/s10518-016-0061-y

[23] S. Casolo, A three- dimensional model for vulnerability analysis of slender medieval masonry towers, Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 1998, 2(4):487-512.

DOI: 10.1080/13632469809350332