Techno-Economical Effects of Adopting Small Capacity Transformers on Ado-Ekiti 11/0.415 kV Power Distribution Networks

Abstract:

The major portion power loss in power system occurs in the components of low voltage (LV) networks. Low voltage distribution system (LVDS) configuration has been observed to contribute significantly to power loss and unacceptable voltage drop in the system due to its structure and higher current flow in the network. The adoption of small capacity transformers as high voltage distribution system (HVDS) configuration is increasingly applied to the network for power loss reduction and the improvement of voltage profile. This study aims to evaluate the technical and economic implication of the use of HVDS configuration on Ado-Ekiti 11/0.415 kV power distribution networks and provide necessary recommendations. The network data was obtained and modeled on NEPLAN software for simulation and technical evaluation of the networks. The existing LV lines were upgraded to high voltage (HV) and remodeled with small capacity transformers and comparative analysis of the technical and economic effects of the networks were carried out. The results obtained showed that there could be feeder capacity increase of 92.03 kW and power loss reduction of 347.17 kW and 459.72 kVar following reconfiguration from LVDS to HVDS. The losses in the transformers and lines were significantly reduced by 37.8% for HVDS configuration when compared with the LVDS configuration. The voltage profile was significantly improved with voltage deviations in the range of ± 0.01 to ± 0.03 of bus voltage for the HVDS network when compared to the existing network. The cost of implementation of the HVDS network substation was calculated to be ₦807,238,715.50 and with the combination of annual savings and an increment in tariff of ₦5/kWh in the billing charge of unit energy consumption resulted in a payback period of 2 to 3 years for the estimated capital investment. This study showed that technical performance of HVDS implementation on the Ado-Ekiti network feeder was better than that of the existing network.

• Periodical: Advanced Engineering Forum (Volume 50)
• Pages: 73-87
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/p-1tgphO
• Online since: September 2023
• Authors: Ademayowa Francis Oni*, Michael Rotimi Adu
• Keywords: Active Power, Completely Self-Protected Transformer, High Voltage, Large Capacity Transformers, Load Flow, Low Capacity Transformers, Low Voltage, Reactive Power, Voltage Deviation, Voltage Quality

References

[1] A.A. Sallam and O.P. Malik, Electric distribution systems, Second Edition Hoboken, New Jersey: JohnWiley & Sons, Inc., 2019.

[2] U.A. Dodo, M.N. Nwohu, I.N. Abubakar, and M.A. Dodo, Appraisal of aggregate technical, commercial and collection losses in Nigeria electricity distribution system, Nigerian Journal of Technology Development (2020) 286-294

DOI: 10.4314/njtd.v17i4.6

[3] H. Orovwode, S. Mathew, E. Amuta, and O. Alashiri, Losses in the Nigeria distribution systems: A review of classification and strategies for mitigation, International Journal of Engineering Research and Technology (2020) 3251-3254.

[4] Nigeria Electricity Regulatory Commission, ATC & C losses, 2019 & 2020 (online) Available: https://nerc.gov.ng/index.php/library/industry-statistics/distribution/119-atc-c-losses. [Accessed: 12th Feb. 2022]

[5] M. Odje, R. Uhmunmwangho, and K. E. Okedu, Aggregated technical and commercial collection loss mitigation through a smart metering application strategy, Frontiers in Energy Research (2021)

DOI: 10.3389/fenrg.2021.703265

[6] A.O. Melodi, and M.R. Adu, A Review of Prevailing Model Energy Loss Values in Typical 11KV Township Distribution System of Nigerian Electricity Sector, 2016 IEEE PES PowerAfrica, Livingstone, Zambia (2016) 31-35.

DOI: 10.1109/powerafrica.2016.7556564

[7] E. Audu, S. O. Paul, and A. Ameh, Privatization of the power sector and poverty of power supply in Nigeria: A policy analysis, International Journal of Development and Sustainability (2017) 1218-1231

[8] O.M. Komolafe, and K.M. Udofia, Review of electrical energy losses in Nigeria, Nigerian Journal of Technology (2020) 246-254.

DOI: 10.4314/njt.v39i1.28

[9] M. T. Alkahayat and S. M. Bashi, Online loss minimization in distribution system incorporating SSS with particle swarm, International Journal of Advance Engineering Research and Science (2016) 170-174

DOI: 10.22161/ijaers/3.12.33

[10] I.S. Majeed, A. Acakpovi, G. Eduful, M.B. Michael, and A. Ruhiya, Migration from low to high voltage distribution system: An Optimization of Selected Unit Transformers Using Linear Programming with Matlab (2019) 552-560.

DOI: 10.1016/j.promfg.2019.05.078

[11] M. Sarwar, Z. Jaffery, A. S. Siddiqui, and I. A. Quadri, Techno-economic feasibility of hvds concept for distribution feeder power loss minimization, Published Article (2015) 1-5

DOI: 10.1109/iicpe.2012.6450376

[12] R. Jain, A.S Siddiqui, and Md. Sarwar, Combined Effect of HVDS and Reconductoring in Distribution Feeder Power Loss Minimization. International Journal of Electrical and Electronics Engineering Research (2013) 59-64.

[13] V. Chawla, and G.S. Brar, Advancement in distribution system through HVDS concept. International Journal of Computer Applications, National Conference on Advancements in Alternate Energy Resources for Rural Applications. (2015) 17-19

[14] S.A. Kumari, B.A. Beevi, J.B. Helonde, and S.M. Shar, Energy efficiency and reliability in electrical distribution network by implementing high voltage distribution system, International Journal of Engineering Science & Research Technology (2018) 164-180

[15] BEDC, Monthly substations report, Benin Electricity Distribution Company Limited, Ado-Ekiti, unpublished. (2021).