The Challenges of Implementing Sustainable Production for One-Way Bottled Drinking Water in Thailand

Abstract:

The paper presents evidence-based evaluation of a sustainable production of one-way bottled drinking water in Thailand with emphasis on open-loop and close-loop processes. Two groups of producers were selected: four top brands and four house brands. In-depth interviews and plant surveys were conducted to explore the producers performances in four categories: corporate social responsibility (CSR), sustainable design, 3 Rs principle and life-cycle management (LCM). The interview and survey transcripts were combined, analyzed and categorized for two sustainable production measures: resource efficiency and pollution reduction. Three most prominent findings are that the top brands moderately perform the sustainable production while the house brands do less well, the resource efficiency measure is much more valued than the pollution reduction, and that the LCM is the most favored category, unlike the CSR. In conclusion, both brands are challenging for improving water efficiency and increasing plastics recyclability and the close-loop process shall be largely adopted among Thai bottled water producers.

• Periodical: Advanced Materials Research (Volumes 807-809)
• Pages: 2897-2910
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.807-809.2897
• Online since: September 2013
• Authors: Taksina Chaiittipornwong, Pomthong Malakul, Dawan Wiwattnadej
• Keywords: 3 R, Corporate Social Responsibility, Drinking Water Bottling System, Life Cycle Management, Sustainable Design, Sustainable Production

References

[1] M. Amano and B. Ness, B. PET Bottle System in Sweden and Japan. Masters' Thesis, International Program in Environmental Science, Lund University (2004).

[2] Y. Takahashi. Sustainable PET Bottle Recycling System in Japan for Second Material Cycle. Graduate Program in Sustainability Science, Graduate School of Frontier Sciences, The University of Tokyo (11 August 2010).

[3] Franklin Associates. Life Cycle Assessment, in: Sustainability Report 2010, Indorama Ventures Public Company Limited (2010), p.8. Information on http: /www. indoramaventures. com.

[4] B. Lehmann, F. Vilaplana, E. Stromberg, W. Suliman and L.R. Cerrato. Comparative LCA on Plastic Packaging. 1N1800, Sweden (25 May 2005), p.8.

[5] JG. Rodwan. Challenge Circumstances Persist: Future Growth Anticipated, U.S. and International Developments and Statistics. Bottled Water 2009 (April-May, 2010). Information on : http: /www. bottledwater. org/files/2009BWstats. pdf.

[6] K. Janthalertlak, editor. Fight Flood. [VCD]. Thai PBS, Bangkok: Investigative News Program (28 October 2011).

[7] N. Chaistapond. PRC Plast (Thailand) Company Limited. Interview (18 July 2012); Personal Communication.

[8] M. Hauschild, J. Jeswiet and L. Alting. From Life Cycle Assessment to Sustainable Production: Status and Perspectives. CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology, Vol. 54 (2) (2005), pp.1-21.

DOI: 10.1016/s0007-8506(07)60017-1

[9] Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). The First National Seminar on Green Growth Policy Tools for Low Carbon Development in Thailand [VCD], Bangkok. (23-24 February 2011).

[10] Ibid.

[11] J.A. Elliott. An Introduction to Sustainable Development. Third edition. London and New York: Taylor & Francis Group (2006).

[12] N.J. Blackburn and G.M. Peters. Atmospheric Water Generation: An Environmentally Friendly Alternative to Bottled Water? Centre for Water and Wastewater Technology, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering. Sydney: Australian Life Cycle Assessment Society. (2009).

[13] B. Lehmann, F. Vilaplana, E. Stromberg, W. Suliman and L.R. Cerrato. (2005) loc. cit.

[14] ESCAP (2011). loc. cit.

[15] W. Power, editor. United Nations Environment Programme [UNEP] and Society of Environment Toxicology and Chemistry [SETAC] Life Cycle Management, How Business Uses It to Decrease Footprint, Create Opportunities and Make Value Chains More Sustainable. (2009).

[16] T.M. Coelho, R. Castro and Jr J.A. Gobbo. PET Containers in Brazil: Opportunities and Challenges of a Logistics Model for Post-Consumer Waste Recycling. Department of Production Engineering, UNESP, Brazil. Resource, Conservation and Recycling, Vol. 55(3) (January 2010), pp.291-99.

DOI: 10.1016/j.resconrec.2010.10.010

[17] F. Gironi and V. Piemonte. Life Cycle Assessment of Polylactic Acid and Polyethylene Terephthalate Bottles for Drinking Water. Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy, Vol. 30(3) (10 September 2010), pp.459-68.

DOI: 10.1002/ep.10490

[18] W. Power (2009). loc. cit.

[19] DuPont. Sustainability Best Practice Series: Life Cycle Thinking (2011). Information on: http: /cyrel. com/na.

[20] M. Amano and B. Ness (2004). loc. cit.

[21] H. Ida. Current Status of Plastics Recycling in Japan. Plastic Waste Management Institute, Japan (12 December 2006). Information on http: /www. pwmi. or. jp.

[22] B. Zhang and F. Kimura. Framework Research on the Greenness Evaluation of Polymer Materials. Advances in Life Cycle Engineering for Sustainable Engineering Businesses. London : Springer-Verlag (2007).

DOI: 10.1007/978-1-84628-935-4_51

[23] H. Srinivas. The 3R Concept and Waste Minimization. Infopac on 3Rs - A GDRC Gateway to 3R Policies, Strategies and Action for Material Efficiency. Information on http: /www. gdrc. org/uem/waste/3r-index. html.

[24] L. Akenji and M. Bengtsson. Is the Customer Really King ? - Stakeholder Analysis for Sustainable Consumption and Production Using the Example of the Packaging Value Chain, in: Sustainable Consumption and Production in the Asia-Pacific Region: Effective Responses in a Resource Constrained World Vol. III (2010).

[25] K. Ramani et al. Integrated Sustainable Life Cycle Design: A Review. Mechanical Design Vol. 132 (September 2010). The Design Automation Committee of ASME.

[26] N.J. Blackburn and G.M. Peters (2009). loc. cit.

[27] W. Chamornmarn. External Environment Analysis: Bottled Water Business (22 June 2008). Information on http: /eiolca. net/LCAexperts/index. html.

[28] A. Veshagh and A. Obagun. Survey of Sustainable Life Cycle Design and Management, 14th CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering. Japan. University of Tokyo (2007), pp.237-42.

DOI: 10.1007/978-1-84628-935-4_41

[29] J. Baauwbroek. CSR in the Netherlands: Changing Consumption and Production Patterns. Industry and Environment Vol. 26(4) (2003), pp.10-12.

[30] S. Wongsemontha. Marketing Strategy and Advertising Tactic. Bangkok: Sam Glur Publishing (1995).

[31] T. Santiwongse. Management in Century 21. 1st edition. Bangkok : Prachoomchang (2007).

[32] Nestlé Waters North America-NWNA. Environmental Life Cycle Assessment of Drinking Water Alternatives & Consumer Beverage Consumption in North America. Information on http: /beveragelcafootprint. com/ (February 5, 2010).

[33] Krones AG. Annual Report. Investor Press GmbH (2011).

[34] B. Zhang and F. Kimura (2007). loc. cit.

[35] M.K. Huber. Bottled Water: The Risks to Our Health, Our Environment, and Our Wallets. School of Public and Environmental Affairs, Honors Thesis (2010), p.25.

[36] M. Barlow. Blue Gold - The Global Water Crisis and the Commodification of the World's Water Supply. Special Report, International Forum on Globalization (2001).

[37] Euromonitor International. Bottled Water-Thailand. Country Sector Briefing (April 2010), p.6. Information on http: /www. euromonitor. com/bottled-water-in-thailand/report.