Assessment of the Stress-Strain State of a Tube Sheet of the Heat Exchanger at Rotary Friction Welding Application

Abstract:

The aim of the study described in this paper is to assess the effect of forces acting on the tube sheet during friction welding on the stress-strain state of the tube sheet.For this, we calculated the stresses and displacements arising in the tube sheet during friction welding. The calculations were carried out in the ANSYS (finite element analysis software package). To carry out the calculations, solid-state models of tube sheets with diameters of 400, 600, 800, 1000, 1200, 1400 mm and thicknesses of 30, 40, 50, 60, 70 mm were created. The diameter of the holes for the heat exchange tubes was chosen equal to 25 mm, the holes are placed on the vertices of an equilateral triangle with a step equal to 32 mm. Then, based on geometric models, grids of 8-node finite elements were created. The calculation model takes into account the symmetry of the geometric model and the character of loading relative to the YZ and XZ planes. The material used was steel with a Poisson's ratio of 0.3 and an elastic modulus of 2,11·10⁵ MPa.As a result of the calculations, it was found that as a result of the action of force factors during friction welding, significant stresses and deformations arise in the tube sheet. The greatest values of deflection and stresses occur in the central sector of the tube sheet in the area of application of force. In this case, the zone of maximum stresses is significantly localized: they are concentrated around the central hole, and movements smoothly increase from the periphery to the center of the tube sheet.The value of this study is that it allowed to determine the need to use special equipment that increases the local stiffness of the tube sheet sector subjected to friction welding.

• Periodical: Materials Science Forum (Volume 991)
• Pages: 70-76
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/MSF.991.70
• Online since: May 2020
• Authors: Andrey Sergeevich Tokarev*, Denis Karetnikov, Rif G. Rizvanov, Ayrat Minnulovich Faнrushin, M.Z. Zaripov
• Keywords: 15Cr5Mo Steel, Energy Saving, Rotary Friction Welding, Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchanger, Tube Bundle, Tube-to-Tube Sheet Joint

References

[1] O. K. Semakina, Mashiny i apparaty khimicheskikh, neftepererabatyvayushchikh i neftekhimicheskikh proizvodstv, Izdatel'stvo Tomskogo politekhnicheskogo universiteta, Tomsk, 2016 (In Russian).

[2] V. I. Krasnov, M. 3. Maksimenko, Remont teploobmennikov, Khimiya, Moskva, 1990 (In Russian).

[3] G. P. Tkachenko, V. M. Brif, Izgotovlenie i remont kozhukhotrubchatoy teploobmennoy apparatury, Mashinostroenie, Moskva, 1980 (In Russian).

[4] R. G. Sharafiev, S.S. Khayrudinova, R.G. Rizvanov, Oborudovanie neftegazopererabatyvayushchikh i neftegazokhimicheskikh proizvodstv, Izdatel'stvo UGNTU, Ufa, 2002 (In Russian).

[5] A.I. Vladimirov, V.I. Peremyachkin, Remont apparatury neftegazopererabotki i neftekhimii, Izdatel'stvo «Neft' i gaz», Moskva, 2001 (In Russian).

[6] A.A. Lashchinskiy, A.R. Tolchinskiy, Osnovy konstruirovaniya i rascheta khimicheskoy apparatury: spravochnik, Al'yanS, Moskva, 2008 (In Russian).

[7] R.S. Zaynullin, Resursosberegayushchie tekhnologii v neftekhimicheskom apparatostroenii, TRANSTEK, Ufa, 2000 (In Russian).

[8] A.V. Bakiev, Tekhnologiya apparatostroeniya, Izd-vo UGNTU, Ufa, 1995 (In Russian).

[9] A.G. Khalimov, A.V. Bakiev, Razrabotka tekhnologii mekhanizirovannoy svarki v srede zashchitnykh gazov staley tipa 15Kh5M, Sbornik materialov konferentsii, RITs UGNTU, Ufa, 1998, pp.51-52 (In Russian).

[10] A.G. Khalimov, R.S. Zaynullin, A.A. Khalimov, Tekhnicheskaya diagnostika i otsenka resursa apparatov, UGNTU, Ufa, 2001 (In Russian).

[11] P.M. Korol'kov, M.V. Khanapetov, Sovremennye metody termicheskoy obrabotki svarnykh soedineniy, Vysshaya shkola, Moskva, 1987 (In Russian).

[12] A.A. Khalimov, N.V. Zharinova, A.G. Khalimov, A.M. Fayrushin, Obespechenie tekhnologicheskoy prochnosti svarnykh soedineniy iz martensitnykh khromistykh staley tipa 15Kh5M, Neftegazovoe delo. 3 (2012) 102-108 (In Russian).

[13] R.G. Rizvanov, D.V. Karetnikov, A.M. Fayrushin, D.Sh. Mulikov, O vozmozhnosti primeneniya svarki treniem dlya izgotovleniya svarnykh trubnykh puchkov iz stali 15Kh5M, Progressivnye tekhnologii i sistemy mashinostroeniya. 4 (2014) 168-173 (In Russian).

[14] R.F. Tukaev, I.G. Ibragimov, A.M. Fayrushin, A.V. Sisanbaev, Sravnitel'nyy analiz svarnykh shvov v uzle «truba – trubnaya reshetka» kozhukhotrubchatogo teploobmennogo apparata iz zharoprochnoy stali 15Kh5M poluchennykh razlichnymi sposobami svarki, Neftegazovoe delo. 5 (2013) 363-375 (In Russian).

[15] A.V. Yakhin, D.V. Karetnikov, R.G. Rizvanov, E.M. Abutalipova, A.G. Gareev, A.S. Tokarev, Sovershenstvovanie tekhnologii izgotovleniya trubnykh puchkov teploobmennykh apparatov iz stali 12Kh18N10T s primeneniem svarki treniem, Khimicheskoe i neftegazovoe mashinostroenie. 11 (2018) 14-16 (In Russian).

[16] R.F. Tukaev, A.M. Fayrushin, T.M. Kuchukov, Sovershenstvovanie tekhnologii izgotovleniya uzla truba - trubnaya reshetka, kozhukhotrubchatogo teploobmennogo apparata iz zharoprochnoy stali 15Kh5M primeneniem lazernoy svarki, Sovremennoe mashinostroenie. Nauka i obrazovanie. 3 (2013) 1179-1185 (In Russian).

[17] Yu. I. Berliner, V. M. Brif, Analiz primenimosti sovremennykh metodov krepleniya trub k trubnym reshetkam, Vysokoproizvoditel'nye metody svarki v khimicheskom i neftyanom mashinostroenii. 3 (1970) 3-12 (In Russian).

[18] A. V. Yakhin, D.V. Karetnikov, R.G. Rizvanov, E.M. Abutalipova, A.G. Gareev, A.S. Tokarev, Improving the technology used in fabrication of tube bundles of heat exchangers produced from 12CR18NI10TI steel by means of friction welding, Chemical and Petroleum Engineering. 11-12 (2019) 801-805.

DOI: 10.1007/s10556-019-00553-5

[19] A. S. Tokarev, D.V. Karetnikov, R.G. Rizvanov, D.Sh. Mulikov, Opredelenie optimal'nykh geometricheskikh razmerov elementov al'ternativnoy konstruktsii kombinirovannykh soedineniy trub s trubnymi reshetkami, Neftegazovoe delo. 1 (2018) 92-101 (In Russian).

[20] D. Sh. Mulikov, A. V. Yakhin, D.V. Karetnikov E.M. Abutalipova, A.S. Tokarev, Problemy i puti sovershenstvovaniya tekhnologicheskogo protsessa polucheniya kombinirovannykh soedineniy trub s trubnymi reshetkami kozhukhotrubchatykh teploobmennykh apparatov, Neftegazovoe delo. 2 (2017) 134-140 (In Russian).

[21] P. G. Rizvanov, D.Sh. Mulikov, D.V. Karetnikov, A.M. Fayrushin, A.S. Tokarev, Evaluation of the Possibility of Obtaining Tube-to-Tube Sheet Welded Joints of 15Cr5Mo Steel by Alternative Technological Process, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering. 2 (2018) 012077.

DOI: 10.1088/1757-899x/317/1/012077

[22] A.S. Zubchenko, M.M. Koloskov, Yu.V. Kashirskiy, Marochnik staley i splavov, Mashinostroenie, Moskva, 2003 (In Russian).